Has Pep Guardiola "ruined" football?

2-0 defeat to Liverpool
Not invincible
Not everyone is a fan
Square peg, round hole
“Not everybody can do it”
Looking to the future
Learning from history
Don’t have the players
Has Pep ruined football?
Is it worse?
Still exciting
Doesn’t work for everyone
Do you agree?
2-0 defeat to Liverpool

Pep Guardiola and Manchester City's losing streak in the Premier League has continued after slipping to a 2-0 defeat away to the surging Liverpool.

 

 

"A shadow of their best"

Micah Richards, speaking on Sky Sports after the game, said, "It's a difficult time, but they're going to find a way to get back. Some of the players have let Guardiola down today. They're a shadow of their best."

"We'll recover our best"

Last month Guardiola told BBC Sport, "Right now, we are not at our best, it's obvious. But it's still November - we'll recover our best." Since then, he has failed to win a game, extending his winless streak to seven games in all competitions. City's continued run of bad form has led to people questioning whether his style of football is working anymore.

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

Not invincible

Guardiola's philosophy and playing style have proven near-invincible since he started his managerial career. However, the last month has shown that his playing style has flaws.

Not everyone is a fan

Pep Guardiola has changed the game of football, but not everyone is a fan of the Spanish manager.

"Ruined football"

Former Manchester United goalkeeper Tim Howard has claimed Pep Guardiola has "ruined football" as teams across the footballing world attempt to parrot his style.

Square peg, round hole

Howard made the comments on CBS Sports, where the former Everton keeper claimed teams were attempting to copy Pep's "expansive style" despite not having the players to do so.

 

“Not everybody can do it”

As Howard claimed, "Pep Guardiola has taught everyone that they can play expansive football. They can't." Before adding, "Not everyone can do it. Three teams in the world can do it really well and so I think you have to be resolved at times."

Looking to the future

Howard's comments came in relation to the US Men's National Team's appointment of Mauricio Pochettino, who Howard believes needs to rely on his principles rather than become another Pep-regen.

Learning from history

As Howard said, "when I looked at his [Pochettino] Tottenham teams, it was two banks of four plus two at the top and then when they broke, they broke with four players, they allowed them to express themselves and then ultimately they were rock-solid defensively or at least tried to be."

Don’t have the players

The US team has struggled in recent years, despite having more players on high-profile teams than in previous eras. Howard's suggestions that these players may not fit Pep's intricate style is probably accurate, with a more direct, physical approach needed.

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

Has Pep ruined football?

There is certainly an argument that Pep has made football more cookie-cutter, with teams across football looking to him for inspiration. Gone are the days of direct passing and long shots, replaced by steady build up, inverted fullbacks and cutbacks.

Is it worse?

Pep's style, which influences so much of modern football, has certainly taken some of the inherent joy out of the game, with ruthless efficiency replacing the emotion that came in previous eras.

Still exciting

However, as the Arsenal vs Man City game earlier in the season showed, players and fans are as emotionally invested as ever, with play style not impacting the relief City players must have felt when they grabbed a 98th-minute equalizer. City players also looked shell-shocked after their defeat to Liverpool.

Doesn’t work for everyone

It is also fair to suggest that given the pervasiveness of Pep's system, European football has become less individualistic, with players now conditioned to play within the system rather than express themselves. There are obviously many exceptions to this, but there is a marked change since 10-20 years ago.

Do you agree?

Do you agree that Pep has "ruined football", or is Tim Howard being hyperbolic? Let us know in the comments!

Want to see more like this? Follow us here for daily sports news, profiles and analysis!

More for you